Sawyer Staffing: Your Insurance Agency Growth Partner
With over two decades of experience in business operations, sales, team building, and hiring, Sawyer Staffing is the go-to partner for Independent Insurance Agencies. We've built entire teams — from Producers and Account Managers to CSRs and licensed staff — customized for today’s insurance landscape.
We don’t just fill roles — we build growth infrastructure. Our team evaluates Producers by sales style, cultural alignment, and long-term agency potential. We find and represent the top 10% of Account Managers in the market — professionals who retain, grow, and elevate your book of business. The days of placing an ad for a role and getting multiple quality applicants are gone. You need a firm who is constantly fnding and evaluating to top talent.
Our placements drive results:
🚀 Helped scale a $3M premium agency to $8M in under 2 years
- ✅ Rebuilt culture at a 50-person agency, leading to a $10M premium increase — without increasing salary
- ✅ Built a ten-person sales army of agents across multiple offices
- ✅ Helped agencies hire to clean up books, accounts, and gain premium before selling
These aren’t outliers — they’re outcomes of our culture-focused, strategy-driven approach. Our knowledge of Markets, Producers, AMs, and Carrier appetites allows us to deliver precise, impactful matches.
Why Agencies Choose Sawyer Staffing
- ✅ 1-Year Replacement Guarantee
- ✅ Flexible Fee Structures — No overpriced % cuts
- ✅ Recurring Client Discounts
- ✅ Retainer-Based Staffing Options for Larger Hiring Needs
Who We Help
- ✅ Independent Insurance Agencies of Any Size
- ✅ Insurance Franchisee Owners
- ✅ Personal Lines, Commercial Lines, Group Benefits, Producers, Account Managers, AE's, CSR's
- ✅ Agencies Prepping for Sale or Cash Out
- ❌ National Call Center Agencies Needing "Bodies"
If you're tired of overpriced recruiters pitching you their outdated approach and out-of-touch models, let's talk.